You look for consistent winners in forums?
That's funny.
Why would any professional share thoughts with you to start with or hand out free advice while their clients pay for it?
I think what you are looking for is a brain-storming session with other non-professionals and hope that you get one or two trades right which is not a really smart strategy.
To make things even easier and to get answers faster just ask your co-worker or cab driver maybe even your neighbour for trades they recommend (Of course this was a sarcastic statement as no investor should ever listen to any of the above mentioned for investment advice...one of the rules of the game is that once everybody knows about it it's too late

)